I bought my table from the former occupant of my room I could not buy his sense-data, which died when he went away, but I could and did buy the confident expectation of more or less similar sense-data. What reason, then, have we for believing that there are such public neutral objects? The first answer that naturally occurs to one is that, although different people may see the table slightly differently, still they all see more or less similar things when they look at the table, and the variations in what they see follow the laws of perspective and reflection of light, so that it is easy to arrive at a permanent object underlying all the different people's sense-data. Thus, if there are to be public neutral objects, which can be in some sense known to many different people, there must be something over and above the private and particular sense-data which appear to various people. But the sense-data are private to each separate person what is immediately present to the sight of one is not immediately present to the sight of another: they all see things from slightly different points of view, and therefore see them slightly differently. When ten people are sitting round a dinner-table, it seems preposterous to maintain that they are not seeing the same tablecloth, the same knives and forks and spoons and glasses. One great reason why it is felt that we must secure a physical object in addition to the sense-data, is that we want the same object for different people. In this chapter we have to see why this is the case. This is an uncomfortable possibility but although it cannot be strictly proved to be false, there is not the slightest reason to suppose that it is true.

Thus if we cannot be sure of the independent existence of objects, we shall be left alone in a desert-it may be that the whole outer world is nothing but a dream, and that we alone exist. For if we cannot be sure of the independent existence of objects, we cannot be sure of the independent existence of other people's bodies, and therefore still less of other people's minds, since we have no grounds for believing in their minds except such as are derived from observing their bodies. Is there a table which has a certain intrinsic nature, and continues to exist when I am not looking, or is the table merely a product of my imagination, a dream-table in a very prolonged dream? This question is of the greatest importance.

In this chapter we have to ask ourselves whether, in any sense at all, there is such a thing as matter.

Comic font download